Tomorrow is Grey Tuesday, a day of protest organized by activisists Downhill Battle, who are rallying against EMI's efforts to stop the sale of a Danger Mouse album that illegally samples The Beatles' The White Album in a remix of Jay-Z's The Black Album.
Coolfer will not take part in this protest, for a number of reasons.
First, EMI owns the recordings that Danger Mouse used to remix Jay-Z's The Black Album. The key word is owns. This is an ownership issue. Since Danger Mouse does not own those songs, he does not have free reign to use them as he sees fit. A master recording of a classic album is not akin to an open source programming code that is free to all users. It's a legally protected work of art. Just because Danger Mouse made this album doesn't mean the world has a right to hear it.
Second, Danger Mouse did not go through the proper channels. That is, he never even asked for permission to use those songs. He didn't attempt to reach an agreement that would allow him to pay royalties to EMI. Music is a business, and like all businesses it is guided by a set of laws. If Danger Mouse is going to be a legitimate recording artist and sell The Grey Album in legitimate places of business, he cannot play by his own rules.
Third, this isn't about censorship. It's about a companies' right to legally protest its assets. The Beatles catalog is a serious business asset. EMI and Apple have the right to choose how The Beatles' legacy will survive. Danger Mouse does not get to make that call.
Fourth, Danger Mouse has and will continue to experience financial gain due to his illegal use of The Beatles' songs...but will he share the money with the owners of the recordings or with the writers of the songs? It is wrong for one artist to benefit from another's creative works and not provide just compensation.
Modern day business has been built upon the protections granted to creative works, whether it be a copyright or a patent. Downhill Battle wants to undermine these keystones of worldwide business. They call it a "copyright cartel," but they offers no alternative to today's copyright law other than to steal from music companies as one sees fit. Until they are part of the public domain, EMI has the legal right to do whatever it pleases with those songs. In the meantime, Downhill Battle should take this matter to the courts, or spur legislation to change copyright law.